Community Blog

Keep up-to-date on postgraduate related issues with our quick reads written by students, postdocs, professors and industry leaders.

Semi-structured interviews: a research guide with an example

Picture of DiscoverPhDs
Two adults talk in rust-red chairs with a recorder and a sheet of paper on a low table between them.

A semi-structured interview is a research interview built around a short guide of open-ended questions. You ask every participant about the same topics, but you can change the order and wording and follow up on what they say. It sits between two other types. In a structured interview, everyone gets the same questions in the same order; in an unstructured one, there are no set topics at all.

In qualitative research and in health research, the semi-structured interview is the most common type. It suits questions about people’s experiences, opinions and beliefs, including sensitive ones.

Published advice suggests five to 10 core questions, or 10 to 12 for an interview of about an hour. How many interviews you need depends on your study, but a common standard is saturation: the point where new interviews stop adding new information. A 2022 systematic review found that empirical studies reached it within 9 to 17 interviews, particularly with fairly similar participants and narrow objectives.

What is a semi-structured interview?

A semi-structured interview is a conversation with a purpose. You prepare a list of guiding questions and ask them in whatever order suits the conversation. Then you add follow-up questions and prompts, depending on what each person tells you. The questions stay the same in substance, so you can compare answers, but each participant has room to explain things in their own way.

This guide is about research interviews for a dissertation or thesis, not job interviews (which use the same name for a different thing).

You can run semi-structured interviews face to face, by phone or online, one to one or in groups. The most common form is the individual, face-to-face, in-depth interview, and that’s the version this article covers. Phone and online interviews suit a small budget and little time to travel. They work as long as it doesn’t matter that interviews take place in different settings.

Calvin Swords was a PhD student at Trinity College Dublin, researching mental health services, when we interviewed him. He told us his data collection ‘was semi-structured interviews with service users, family members, carers, professionals, and policymakers in mental health services’. Hearing from all these perspectives was, in his words, ‘a very privileged, but enjoyable position to be in’. You can read more in our interview with Calvin.

Structured vs semi-structured vs unstructured interviews

The three types differ in how much you decide before the interview starts. The more you fix in advance, the easier the answers are to compare, and the less room participants have to raise things you didn’t expect.

Structured Semi-structured Unstructured
Questions Fully worded in advance A guide of open-ended questions and planned prompts No set topics; the conversation flows from the context
Order The same for everyone Can change as the conversation develops Led by the conversation
Follow-up questions None beyond the fixed questions Planned and unplanned follow-ups are central Whatever arises
What you get Uniform answers that are easy to compare Comparable answers with individual detail Rich, wide-ranging accounts that are hard to pull together
Best for Collecting the same facts from everyone Experiences, opinions and attitudes on a defined topic Topics where little is known yet

Sources: University of Reading interviews guide; Imperial College London educational research toolkit; DeJonckheere and Vaughn (2019).

Structured interviews need less interviewing skill than unstructured ones. Semi-structured interviews bring their own risk: losing focus. If you drift too far from your questions, you can lose the thread of the interview. And a semi-structured format doesn’t always give participants room to show their own perspective, so leave space for them to lead.

Semi-structured interviews or focus groups? Individual interviews can let you probe one person’s account in depth and avoid one voice dominating a group. They also suit sensitive topics, where people may not speak freely in front of others. Focus groups gather several views at once: the same 2022 review found saturation within four to eight focus group discussions.

When to use semi-structured interviews: advantages and disadvantages

Semi-structured interviews give you depth. They work well when you want to:

  • collect open-ended, qualitative data about a topic you’ve already defined;
  • explore participants’ thoughts, feelings and beliefs;
  • discuss personal or sensitive issues in detail;
  • follow up on answers in a way a questionnaire can’t.

In a mixed methods study, interviews can come before a quantitative phase, such as a survey, to explore new ideas. Or they can come after it, to explain the results. If you’re still deciding where interviews fit, our guide to types of research sets out the main approaches.

They’re the wrong choice when you need answers from a large group or have very little time. Because you’ll usually talk to a small number of people, you can’t generalise your findings to a whole population. The quality of the data also often depends on your skill as an interviewer. And anonymity is hard to guarantee with interviews.

Common mistake: underestimating the time. Recruiting participants, interviewing, transcribing and analysing all take far longer than they look on a project plan. Build that time into your schedule before you commit to interviews.

How to write a semi-structured interview guide

Your interview guide (also called an interview protocol or topic guide) is the plan you take into each interview. It isn’t a script you read word for word: you’ll use it flexibly to fit each participant. A good guide covers:

  • a short introduction to the study and the purpose of the interview;
  • how the interview will be recorded;
  • confidentiality, and a reminder about informed consent;
  • your main questions, with prompts under each;
  • closing comments, thanks and your contact details.

Types of question

A semi-structured guide uses four kinds of question, set out in DeJonckheere and Vaughn’s open-access guide to semi-structured interviewing.

Type of question What it’s for Example
Opening (‘grand tour’) question Starts the conversation with something easy that the participant knows a lot about ‘Tell me about your final year so far.’
Core questions Answer your research question; usually asked of every participant ‘How did you decide on your dissertation topic?’
Planned follow-up questions Ask for more detail on a core question, depending on the answer ‘You mentioned your supervisor. What part did they play?’
Unplanned follow-up questions Pick up something the participant raised that you didn’t expect ‘You said you nearly changed topic. Can you tell me more about that?’

Question types from DeJonckheere and Vaughn (2019); the examples are ours.

How to word your questions

Keep every question open, neutral and clear. In practice that means:

  • Ask one question at a time. Two questions in one sentence put pressure on the participant.
  • Avoid questions that invite a yes or no. They can turn the interview into a quiz.
  • Avoid leading wording and jargon. Use the participant’s everyday language, not your discipline’s.
  • Be careful with ‘why’. It can make people feel defensive; try ‘How did you come to…?’ instead.
  • Start easy and leave demographics until the end (or spread them through the interview), unless you need some background at the start to make sense of the rest.

How many questions, and how long?

Published advice ranges from five to 10 core questions plus follow-ups, to 10 to 12 questions for an interview of about an hour. Treat both as starting points, and pilot your guide first with someone like your participants. A pilot shows you whether the questions make sense and whether you can cover them in the time.

Your guide can also change as you go. Data collection and analysis happen together in qualitative research, so you can drop questions that don’t work and add prompts for new topics participants raise.

Semi-structured interview example: a template guide

Say you’re researching how final-year engineering students choose their dissertation project. A guide for that study might look like the one below. It’s our illustration, not a real study, and a full guide would have more core questions.

  1. Introduction. Thank the participant and explain the purpose of the study and how long it will take. Confirm they’ve signed the consent form, ask permission to record, and remind them they can skip any question or stop at any time.
  2. Opening question. ‘Tell me about your final year so far.’
  3. Core question 1. ‘How did you go about choosing your dissertation project?’ Prompts: ‘Who did you talk to?’ ‘What information did you use?’
  4. Core question 2. ‘What mattered most to you when you made the decision?’ Prompts: ‘Can you give me an example?’ ‘How did that compare with other options?’
  5. Core question 3. ‘Looking back, how do you feel about the choice you made?’ Prompts: ‘What would you do differently?’
  6. Background questions. Course, year of study and any other details your analysis needs.
  7. Closing. ‘Is there anything else you’d like to add that we haven’t covered?’ Thank them, explain what happens next and give your contact details.

For a real example, see the University of Reading’s guide to running an interview. It was written for staff evaluating their teaching, and includes a sample interview guide and a consent form you can adapt.

How many semi-structured interviews do you need?

There’s no fixed number: it depends on your aim, how similar your participants are and how you’ll analyse the data. A common standard is saturation. Some researchers use ‘information power’ instead. It ties sample size to five things: your aim, how similar your participants are, the theory you use, interview quality and your analysis.

A 2022 systematic review of 23 studies that tested saturation gives useful benchmarks. Among the 17 that used real data, interview studies reached saturation within a narrow range of 9 to 17 interviews. That was particularly true when the participants were fairly similar and the objectives narrowly defined. Outliers, such as studies across several countries, needed larger samples.

In family medicine research, a meaningful interview project can involve as few as 8 to 12 participants. So if you’re interviewing one group about a focused question, around a dozen interviews is a reasonable starting point for planning. Plan for more interviews if your groups differ or your question is broad. Whatever number you choose, justify it for your own study and check what your supervisor and programme expect.

How you choose participants matters as much as how many. Qualitative studies typically use purposive sampling, and our guide to sampling methods compares the alternatives.

Ethics, consent and recording

Check whether your project needs ethics approval before you contact anyone. In the UK, the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) sets out six principles for ethical research. Three bear most directly on interviews:

  • research should aim to maximise benefit for individuals and society and minimise risk and harm;
  • the rights and dignity of individuals and groups should be respected;
  • wherever possible, participation should be voluntary and appropriately informed.

In practice, that means giving participants an information sheet and a consent form. Tell them how long the interview will take and why they’ve been chosen. They should know they can refuse to answer questions or withdraw at any time, including during the interview. Ask permission to record, and tell them they can say no.

Think about power, too. If you’re interviewing people you teach, treat or work with, make clear that taking part (or not) won’t affect that relationship. And plan how you’ll protect the data. Anonymise transcripts as you go, store recordings securely and follow your ethics committee’s rules on keeping and deleting them.

How to conduct a semi-structured interview

Good interviews depend on preparation as much as on what happens in the room.

Before the interview. Choose a quiet, private place where you won’t be interrupted and can record clearly. Test your recording equipment there first. If you’re interviewing alone, use two recording devices in case one fails.

At the start. Spend a moment putting the participant at ease. Explain the study, go through consent, describe how the interview will run and check the recorder is working. Then begin with your easy opening question.

During the interview. Listen more than you talk. Keep a warm, conversational tone, and treat the participant as the expert on their own experience. Use prompts to draw out detail:

Probing technique What you do Example
Wait time Stay silent after a question so they have time to think (Pause; don’t fill the silence)
Echo Repeat or summarise what they said ‘So you picked the project your friends were doing…’
Verbal agreement Encourage them to keep going ‘Mm… I see…’
Expansion Ask them to say more ‘What happened next?’
Explanation Ask what they meant by a word or phrase ‘What do you mean when you say the choice felt "rushed"?’

Techniques from DeJonckheere and Vaughn (2019), adapted from Bernard; the examples are ours.

If the conversation drifts too far off topic, steer it back politely. Near the end, give the participant the final say: ask if there’s anything they’d like to add.

Straight afterwards. Check the recording worked. If it didn’t, write down everything you remember at once.

Either way, note your first thoughts while they’re fresh: what you learned, what worked and which questions fell flat. These notes (often called memos) improve your next interview and start your analysis.

After the semi-structured interview: transcription and analysis

Have your interviews transcribed word for word, so you can work with participants’ exact language. Transcription is slow if you do it yourself and costly if you pay someone, so allow time and budget for it. Anonymise names and identifying details as you go.

Analysis usually means coding the transcripts, grouping the codes into themes and looking for patterns within and across interviews. Many interview studies use thematic analysis to do this. Software such as NVivo, ATLAS.ti or MAXQDA can help you organise the material. It won’t do the thinking for you, though, and it takes time to learn.

Your methodology chapter should explain why you chose semi-structured interviews, who took part and how you analysed the data. Our guide to dissertation structure shows where that chapter fits. When you write up, show how you made your findings trustworthy. One common way is to judge them on four criteria:

  • credibility: do the findings fairly represent the data?
  • transferability: could they apply in other settings?
  • confirmability: are they free of your own bias?
  • dependability: are they consistent over time?

Use participants’ own words in quotes to support each theme.

Next steps

If semi-structured interviews suit your project, start by drafting your guide from your research question. Then check what ethics approval you need, and pilot the guide with someone like your participants. Once the interviews are done, our guide to thematic analysis takes you through turning transcripts into findings.

Sources

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest

Join

Thousands

Join thousands of other students and stay up to date with the latest PhD programmes, funding opportunities and advice.

Browse PhDs Now

Other Posts
Interviews
Adam Netzer Zimmer

Adam’s about to start his fifth year of PhD research at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, where he’s earning a doctorate in anthropology as an affiliated researcher with the University of Iceland’s medical school.

Read More »
DiscoverPhDs_Aaron Jones_Profile
Aaron Jones

Aaron’s now writing up his PhD thesis at the University of Birmingham. His research has investigated the Impact and Mitigation of Wavefront Distortions in Precision Interferometry.

Read More »

Browse PhDs Now

Join Thousands of Students

Join thousands of other students and stay up to date with the latest PhD programmes, funding opportunities and advice.